Stanford Social Innovation Review : Informing and inspiring leaders of social change

SUBSCRIBE | HELP

Economic Development

Accelerating Job Creation Results

An innovative investment opportunity to increase results—not rhetoric—on quality job creation for all.

All the talk about job creation has become cheap, and in an election year we don't expect the posturing around "job creators" to stop anytime soon. Delivering results, not rhetoric, on matters of small business growth and job creation requires a new model based on equity to ensure that all residents co-create and prosper from that growth. 

The quality of jobs, and the degree to which the people with marginalized socioeconomic status are able to participate in the growth and transformation of our economy, will affect our society for years to come. America cannot achieve the transformation it seeks without investing in people who have historically been excluded.

To build an economy that works for all, we must shed the scarcity mindset that plagues foundations, change our notion of investment "risk," and deploy larger amounts investment capital with fewer strings attached to ensure that enough resources are available to do whatever is necessary to succeed.

The more we invest in each other—especially the most vulnerable—the better off we all will be. By doing good, we will all prosper.

Scale is critical

While there are many successful programs that help people become entrepreneurs, the challenge is to achieve greater scale—helping existing small businesses grow so that they can generate more jobs for the people who need them most. All entrepreneurs deserve the high-quality services and resource-rich networks necessary to bring their innovations to scale. In the effort to help more organizations achieve this growth, here are a few examples of how we at Inner City Advisors (ICA) go about doing this.

ICA is a local nonprofit with a nationally recognized business-accelerating model that provides entrepreneurship education, management consulting, quality advice, and investment capital to socially responsible entrepreneurs. With more than a decade of experience, ICA has created thousands of jobs by helping to scale local startups such as Revolution Foods, Blue Bottle Coffee, Back to the Roots, Prather Ranch Meat Co., and Premier Organics, among other socially responsible entrepreneurs.

ICA_What_We_Do

ICA grows socially responsible businesses.

ICA has leveraged its partnerships to increase the size and strength of our entrepreneurial support ecosystem, mobilizing government, private business, nonprofits, and the public to work in concert toward supporting entrepreneurs and creating good jobs. We are leading this charge by launching an innovative investment fund that enables local entrepreneurs to overcome their biggest barrier to scale, and to maximize the creation of good jobs and equity for all residents.

I’ve said before that ICA's model is a powerful case study for how to build an equitable economy that works for all people. Right now we need more resources invested into our model to dramatically increase its impact. There are too many underemployed people who can't afford incremental growth.

Leveraging smart capital investments to accelerate job creation

In direct response to the challenges our companies face in accessing smart, flexible capital, ICA secured seed investment from the Y&H Soda Foundation to structure an investment fund with two simple but far-reaching objectives:

  • Capitalize on an overlooked opportunity by focusing on inner city companies as a new asset class.
  • Create new jobs and wealth for inner city residents through the expansion of the businesses in which investments are made.

The rigor of this structure prioritizes our mission returns and will dramatically increase our social impact.

The ICA Fund invests in companies throughout the Bay Area to help these enterprises achieve equitable growth. In partnership with mission-aligned banks and investors, the ICA Fund offers debt products and alternative investment vehicles that support the growth objectives of ICA Portfolio Companies. Based on our analysis in 2011, the average debt financing need for ICA companies was $432,200. To the end, the ICA Fund's investments are expected to range in size from $100,000 to $500,000, filling a current void in the capital sector.

ICA_Impact_Data

Good jobs, wages, and revenues are ICA’s three key indicators for success.

We know that there is a considerable opportunity to produce good financial and social returns by investing in local companies through a well-structured and well-executed investment strategy. The strategy is underscored by the implementation of ICA's full range of services—including high-caliber advising, financial forecasting, positioning companies for capital or liquidity events, and growth management—to maximize the return on investment.

The road to 25,000 Bay Area jobs

ICA is on a relentless mission to create 25,000 Bay Area jobs on an annual basis, and it requires an all-in investment from everyone in this region. At this point in time when job creation is so vital to our economy, a more intentional strategy is required to boost such classic measures of successful business outcomes, including: revenue, profit, market penetration, and product line development.

Our impact means nothing if it does not inspire investment from other stakeholders to act now and make bigger investments in our economic development model of quality job creation. Models that offer technical and financial resources (like ICA) are a critical link in the chain of service offerings that have a mission to build thriving communities. These models need more investments and philanthropic resources. Technical service providers act as the catalyst for positioning entrepreneurs for growth and scale. 

We believe in the power of venture philanthropy (public and private) and partnering with organizations to provide the safety net that all stakeholders need to take the plunge into building thriving and economically diverse inner city communities. Together we can maximize the value to scale entrepreneurs and create an economy that works for all people.

Tracker Pixel for Entry
 

COMMENTS

  • Good jobs for all's avatar

    BY Good jobs for all

    ON October 24, 2012 12:50 PM

    It’s very refreshing to read this news and know that a local solution is generating results. Thank you for these examples, Jose. ICA has a newfound supporter!

  • Kudos to ICA, its great to see a model like this where people who have been left out of the conversation are now a critical part of the equation.

  • There has been a bubble full of rhetoric and an empty bowl of implementation. Sounds like ICA is filling that bowl with solutions that create jobs and change lives. Nice work.

  • This is truly awesome. I have been working on a social venture selling consumer products in SF. It has been disheartening to find so many investors only looking for tech startups that can make them their big bucks.

    The model behind ICA is beautiful - taking a startup accelerator model and using it to focus on social impact, inner city jobs, and all the while creating business success that brings socially conscious products to the world.

    Only downside is their criteria for $1-5M in revenue, but it is understandable to want orgs with initial traction. We will definitely be looking into this once we hit our first M.

    Thanks Jose for this article and your valuable work!

  • BY Jose Corona

    ON October 24, 2012 05:26 PM

    JP:  Thank you for your kind words.  We are always looking for feedback on how we can continue to get better and continue to offer relevant services to entrepreneurs and small businesses.  The $1-5MM criteria is not set in stone and, in fact, we work with a lot of businesses at much earlier stages.  I encourage you to reach out to ICA and I am confident that there are ways in which we can/will add value.  Most Sincerely, Jose.

  • Luz Montes's avatar

    BY Luz Montes

    ON October 29, 2012 06:57 PM

    It would be great for traditional foundations and investment companies to invest in an organization like ICA so they can continue to impact the communities in which they serve but as many nonprofits can testify, the traditional methods no longer work. It is time to take America back and give power to the individuals who strive to make this nation great. Has ICA ever launched an Indiegogo campaign? I recently viewed a campaign for “Buying America Back” http://www.indiegogo.com/buyingamericaback?show_todos=true for some odd reason the words they quoted from the poet, Seamus Heaney “Hope is not optimism, which expects things to turn out well, but something rooted in the conviction that there is good worth working for” triggered a connection with this article. ICA seems to have a model “good worth working for” and towards. Good luck during these hard economic times and continue to positively impact inner cities nation wide! It is time to turn the philanthropy triangle upside down and power the people.

Leave a Comment

 
 
 
 
 

Please enter the word you see in the image below: