Stanford Social Innovation Review

Stanford Social Innovation Review is an award-winning magazine covering best strategies for nonprofits, foundations, and socially responsible businesses. Published quarterly by the Stanford Graduate School of Business.

Subscriber Login



Auto-login on future visits

Forgot your password?
Obtain a login

More

It’s the Destination

THE BLUE SWEATER by Jacqueline Novogratz

By Pamela Hartigan
 Spring 2009   4 comments | Comment on this article
Book  Image

The Blue Sweater

Jacqueline Novogratz

Buy the book »

If you don’t know where you’re going, any road will take you there, the Cheshire Cat tells Alice when she asks for directions in Wonderland. But what if Alice had known exactly where she wanted to end up, and just didn’t know which road would get her there? That is the challenge that entrepreneurs with a social mission face every day.

In her autobiography, The Blue Sweater, Acumen Fund founder and CEO Jacqueline Novogratz engagingly captures one such mission in need of the right road. In her case, she hopes to use the power of markets to achieve social transformation, primarily through providing economic opportunity to the poor and marginalized. Through the course of the book she proves herself one of the increasing number of “ordinary” people who accomplish the extraordinary through sheer courage, fortitude, resilience, and the pursuit of a mission much larger than any one person could ever accomplish in a lifetime. And her story might also provide the missing piece for those struggling to change the world: her great willingness to listen to, and learn from, all those she comes across during her journey.

Novogratz’s journey begins as a new college graduate, when she joins Chase Manhattan Bank and flies around the world to review the bank’s loans. She loves banking, but as it turns out, she loves the idea of lending to the poor even more, and Chase is not about to do that—this is the 1980s, after all. So despite the personal validation, prestige, and security offered by such an institution, she resigns to accept a position at a nonprofit that uses the platform of the African Development Bank (ADB) to foster local organizations that promote economic development in West Africa.

With no ability to speak French or knowledge of the region, and a huge dose of naïveté, she lands in Africa—first in Kenya, then on trips throughout the region. We follow her as she is rejected by the African women leaders who disapprove of having a young American woman in a central position at the ADB, when it should have been one of them. We accompany her to Rwanda, where she works alongside Rwandan women leaders to set up a microfinance organization and struggles to get borrowers to take their responsibilities to repay seriously.

It is this section of the book that probably most endears us to the author. There is her downright funny depiction of her “too American” attempts to convert shy Rwandan women into forward, aggressive sales agents at a local bakery where she was consulting. And she clearly shows us how she herself was transformed by the process of seeking to transform others, despite her admission that “we were getting our feet wet and didn’t know exactly what we were doing.” (How many times have we ever felt that way?) She comes to understand that economic development and social change cannot be imposed from without. They must be sought and grasped by the individual pursuing opportunities for self-realization.

After her two-year sojourn in Africa, Novogratz returns to the United States for a stint with the World Bank in Washington, D.C., ending up back in Africa, this time Gambia. And here begins a tragic subplot, the massive waste of financial and human resources channeled by well meaning development agencies. Novogratz’s experiences show, governments too often derail the money intended to help the poor so that it ends up padding civil servants’ pockets instead. This part of the book is not a surprise, unfortunately. That’s because we have heard of—and many of us have witnessed—the outrageous corruption that occurs in the name of development.

The most gripping part of Novogratz’s story comes next—after she has gotten her MBA from the Stanford Graduate School of Business and made her first official foray into philanthropy as a Rockefeller Foundation Warren Weaver fellow. She returns to Rwanda post-genocide, to the aftermath of the civil and ethnic war in which close to a million people lost their lives over a period of three months. Her efforts to discover for herself the fate of each of her Rwandan colleagues is simultaneously riveting, wrenching, and uplifting.

Novogratz’s creation of the Acumen Fund is a logical next path in her quest to apply business principles to social change: The venture capital fund invests in social entrepreneurs working to help the world’s poor. In this section she highlights the early years of the fund, its underlying principles, and her exposure to Asia, specifically to remarkable entrepreneurs who are my heroes, too: the late Dr. Govindappa Venkataswamy, founder of Aravind Eye Hospital; Satyan Mishra, founder of Drishtee; Amitabha Sadangi of IDE-India; Tasneem Siddiqui, founder of Saiban; and Roshaneh Zafar, founder of the Kashf Foundation.

And there the book ends, its readers left wondering what path this “ordinary” extraordinary woman will take next.

So that they will succeed as well as she has in their own missions, I hope readers also take away that ultimately, the book is a wonderful lesson in the importance of empathy—not one that comes from a place of superiority, but one born from a profound humility and belief that from her to whom much is given, much is expected.


Pamela Hartigan is the director of the Skoll Centre for Social Entrepreneurship at the University of Oxford’s Saïd Business School. She is the coauthor of The Power of Unreasonable People: How Social Entrepreneurs Create Markets That Change the World.

Comments

Chat Bubble Comment

This is indeed a great story of grit and conviction but more often it is seen that many such change agents in the making give up when they encounter outrageous corruption or too much of resistance from certain quarters. My suggestion is philanthropic funds like Acumen should set-up and fund some technical support agencies (TSAs) which can provide critical support in times of crisis to such individuals and their networks. These TSAs should also deal in grievance redressal to prove their worth for the communities that they are serving. Over a period of time these TSAs would extend their support to all worthy and willing micro-entreprenurs in a given geographical territory to justify the economics of their existence and thus convert into Business Development Service Providers, for which the takers are increasing by leaps and bounds.

»» Posted by: Raj Jani on April 4, 2009 11:20 PM

Chat Bubble Comment

I would tend to agree with Raj Jani that there is a critical need for
technical support agencies. I do not think however, that the role of
the Acumen Fund is to provide TA to a wide variety of enterprises, 
rather to focus their technical, capacity building efforts and
expertise on those organizations they invest in. It is exciting to
see Acumen and the organizations they support, break through the
Microfinance ceiling and create sustainable (don’t much like this
word), replicable and large scale enterprises that create jobs and
change the world.

I have admired Acumen for a number of years and believe that the
model developed by Jacqueline exemplifies the best in taking
philanthropy to the next step, that being as a starter, redefining
the terms donor and donation, replacing them with investor and
investment. Although in some ways symbolic, these new terms imply
accountability, measurement and good business practices.

When I read books, I like to mark those passages that I would like to
remember and refer back to them by drawing a line next to the
sentences. With this book, I found that here was hardly a sentence
that did not warrant marking. After a while, I gave up, lines running
down the full length of each page.

I was particularly interested in Jacqueline’s emphasis on the
ability to listen. How many times have we all marveled at the
importance Barack Obama has placed on this important attribute. As
Jacqueline states, “If only we had listened.” I also see an analogy
with her description of the use of fear by corrupt politicians in
Rwanda with the tactics of fear promulgated by the Bush
Administration after 911. Fear freezes ones mind, body and soul. 
Lastly, I agree with her that it is vitally important for NGO’s and
business’s in this sector to be willing to share failures, not only
successes. How often do we repeat failure because organizations are
afraid to admit and in turn share failure least their donors cease
funding.

I love “patient capital.”  The Blue Sweater is a must for anyone
wanting to “change the world”. Thank you Jacqueline.

Chip Raymond
Former President, The Citi Foundation
Partner, Hudson Heights Partners, NYC

»» Posted by: Chip Raymond on April 6, 2009 12:38 PM

Chat Bubble Comment

A gripping story of one woman’s strugge and empathy for the world’s poor . I have not read the book but through this article I sensed what Jacqueline went through . Jacqueline you are an inspiration . Thank you .

»» Posted by: Deepak Sethi on June 29, 2009 06:29 AM

Chat Bubble Comment

What an effort and inspiration ! YES, for too long we have had ’ urban solutions for rural problems ( ? ) Does it always have to imply that walking barefoot - on HIS OWN FAMILIAR LAND and not having / using electricity and consuming simple but traditional, local food -  the person is poor / deprived. Snatching away his skills of livelihood and local resources for urban welfare (?) is to be stopped at first.

»» Posted by: Ramanand Kowta on June 30, 2009 07:18 AM

Chat Bubble Post a Comment

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL:

Remember my personal information

Please enter the word you see in the image below: